Custom Sugar Cookies
We make it easy to order custom sugar cookies from Sweets by Tyler. Already have an idea? Fantastic, let’s chat and get you on the calendar.
Is this your first time ordering cookies, or are you looking for a little inspiration? You’re in the right spot to learn about the flavors, designs, and our pricing.
Shapes and Decorations
Most designs fall under our standard custom cookie pricing. These include standard shapes that we have a cookie cutter for, up to three colors, and one or two layers. Cookies with four or more colors, custom shapes, or more than two layers take additional time to create and have slightly higher pricing to cover the additional time required.
Standard Custom Cookies
Complex Custom Cookies
Packaging Options
We pack our sugar cookies in flat, compostable, cookie boxes to help protect them in transit, unless otherwise specified. We have additional options available for a small charge, upon request. If you don’t see what you’re looking for, just give us a shout and we’ll do our best to make it happen.
Individually Wrapped
Each cookie is individually sealed in a cellophane bag.
Display Trays
We’ll work to find the right tray for your event.
Celebration Package
Cookies are packed in a box with a display window with a ribbon.
Pricing for Frosted Vanilla Sugar Cookies
Standard
- Minimum 2 Dozen
- 1 Flavor, 2 Designs
- 2-3 Colors, 1-2 Layers
- Typically 3-4 inch cookies
Complex
- Minimum 2 Dozen
- 1 Flavor, 2-3 Designs
- 4+ Colors, 3+ Layers
- Typically 3-4 inch cookies
GET IN TOUCH
Start your cookie order
🦑 Release the Kraken! ⚓️ Who else is excited about the @seattlekraken home opener at Climate Pledge Arena tonight!? We were thrilled to work with the Kraken team to bring these cookies to the community – hopefully @nhlbuoy liked them too! Good luck tonight!
.
.
.
.
.
@climatepledgearena
#seattlekraken #seattlekrakenhockey #kraken #krakenhomeopener #kraken #nhl #hockey #seattlehockey #newseason #letsgokraken #seakraken #releasethekraken #defendthedeep #seattle #seattlesports #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #seattlecookies #cookies #frostedsugarcookies #cookiesofig #cookiesofinsta #sportscookies #hockeycookies #climatepledgearena #seattlecenter #hockeynight #seattledesserts #homeopener #sugarcookie #sugarcookies
3 weeks ago
💚 Congrats, Nick and Mandy! 👩❤️👨 These nature-inspired, earth-tone cookies were the perfect addition to such a special day in this couple’s life. We love bringing each person’s unique style to life through our cookies.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
#weddingcookie #bridecookies #weddingshowercookies #bridalshowercookies #bridalcookies #weddingcookies #engagementcookies #lovecookies #earthtonecookies #naturecookies #greencookies #customsugarcookies #cookieset #customcookies #uniquecookies #cookie #cookies #sugarcookie #sugarcookies #cookiesofig #cookiesofinsta #cookiedecorating #frostedsugarcookies #seattle #pnw #pnwwedding #seattlewedding #seattlebakery #seattlecookies #seattledesserts
1 month ago
🛫 Celebrating a legendary airline 👨✈️ This week we made cookies for the Pan Am Museum Foundation’s Gala in Seattle. Every attendee received a gift wrapped Pan Am logo cookie to celebrate the occasion and show appreciation for their attendance!
.
.
.
.
.
.
#panam #panamfoundation #panamlogo #retrologo #historyofflight #panamcookies #airlinelogocookies #cookies #sugarcookies #sugarcookiesofinstagram #sugarcookieart #sugarcookiedecorating #fundraisercookies #eventcookies #partycookies #cookiesofig #cookiesofinsta #seattlecookies #seattlebakery #seattlebaker #seattlefood #seattlefoodscene #seattlefoodblogger #seattle #seattlebusiness #supportlocal #frostedsugarcookies #cookiedecorating #cookiegifts #cookiegiftbox
2 months ago
🚀 Celebrating Aki’s First Birthday 🪐 These “first trip around the sun” cookies were a blast to create! Bright colors and a variety of textures made this set of cookies especially fun.
.
.
.
.
.
.
#firstbirthdaycookies #birthdaycookies #birthdaycookieset #cookies #sugarcookiesofinstagram #sugarcookies #sugarcookiesdecorating #sugarcookieart #babyaki #babycookies #birthdaycookie #spacecookies #rocketcookies #mooncookies #jupitercookies #planetcookies #firsttriparoundthesuncookies #firsttriparoundthesun #cookiesofig #seattle #seattledesserts #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #seattlebaby #seattleparents #seattlemom #seattlecookies #localbaker #cookiedecorating #frostedsugarcookies
2 months ago
👑 Happy Birthday Princess Emma 👸🏻 Celebrating a very magical three year old’s birthday with pink and purple princess cookies! @amandabnguyen we hope these cookies added a special touch to your celebration 🩷💜
.
.
.
.
.
.
#princesscookies #pinkandpurple #pinkandpurplecookies #pinkprincess #pinkprincesscookies #purpleprincess #purpleprincesscookies #birthdaycookies #birthdayparty #birthdaytheme #princesstheme #princessbirthdayparty #princessbirthdaycookies #princessthemedcookies #3rdbirthday #thirdbirthday #3rdbirthdaycookies #thirdbirthdaycookies #seattle #seattlecookies #seattledesserts #seattlefood #seattlefoodscene #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #cookies #sugarcookies #cookiegram #instacookies #cookiesofig
2 months ago
🍾 All glam for this rosé soirée 💕 Decorated with gold accents and highlighted by a dusting of silver, these cookies were made with glitz and glamor in mind. Thank you @myeraevents for another fun collab!
.
.
.
.
.
.
#roseallday #roséallday #rosésoirée #rosesoiree #roseparty #champagne #champagnecookies #pinkchampagne #cookiesandchampagne #champagneandcookies #rosechampagne #pinkcookies #goldcookies #cookies #cookiesofig #cookiesofinsta #cookiegram #cookieset #seattle #seattlecookies #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #seattledesserts #seattlefood #sugarcookies #sugarcookieart #sugarcookiedecorating #cookiedecorating #frostedsugarcookies #cookiegifts
3 months ago
👰♀️ Mehndi inspired wedding cookies 🩷 These cookies are bright, colorful displays of love and tradition. Each cookie is adorned with a design that you might find applied in henna to a bride’s hands and feet.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
#henna #hennacookies #mehndi #mehndicookies #weddingcookies #weddingcookie #bridalcookies #bridecookies #mehndibride #hennabridal #hennabride #ceremonycookies #weddingdessert #weddingdesserts #seattle #seattlecookies #seattlebakery #seattlebaker #seattlemehndi #seattlehenna #seattlewedding #seattleweddings #cookie #cookies #cookiegram #cookiesofig #cookieart #cookieartist #sugarcookie #sugarcookiesofinstagram
3 months ago
🍼 It’s baby shower season! 🌞 We love seeing all of the fun and unique ways our community celebrates new additions. How do you celebrate?
.
.
.
.
.
.
#babyshower #babyshowerideas #seattlebaby #seattlebabyshower #seattleparents #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #seattledesserts #seattlecookies #pnwbaby #pnwbaby #babyshowercookies #babycookies #cookie #cookies #cookiegram #cookieset #cookiedecorating #cookieart #frostedsugarcookies #sugarcookies #sugarcookiesofinstagram #sugarcookiedecorator #cookieartist #seattle #seattlewa #seattlefood #seattlefoodie #shorelinewa #bellevuewa #edmondswa
4 months ago
🎓 Congrats Class of 2025 🧡 Your hard work has paid off! We hope you get to celebrate in style like this grad!
.
.
.
.
.
#classof2025 #classof25 #graduated #graduation #graduation2025 #2025grad #graduationcookies #graduationparty #gradparty #gradphotos #gradnight #2025vibes #seattle #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #seattlecookies #seattlefood #seattledesserts #seattlefoodie #seattlefoodscene #cookie #cookies #cookiegram #cookiesofig #sugarcookies #sugarcookie #frostedsugarcookies #cookieset #cookiedecorating #cookiedecorator
5 months ago
Let’s work together on your
next corporate gift project!
Looking for a special gift that will leave your clients wanting more?