Custom Sugar Cookies
We make it easy to order custom sugar cookies from Sweets by Tyler. Already have an idea? Fantastic, let’s chat and get you on the calendar.
Is this your first time ordering cookies, or are you looking for a little inspiration? You’re in the right spot to learn about the flavors, designs, and our pricing.
Shapes and Decorations
Most designs fall under our standard custom cookie pricing. These include standard shapes that we have a cookie cutter for, up to three colors, and one or two layers. Cookies with four or more colors, custom shapes, or more than two layers take additional time to create and have slightly higher pricing to cover the additional time required.
Standard Custom Cookies
Complex Custom Cookies
Packaging Options
We pack our sugar cookies in flat, compostable, cookie boxes to help protect them in transit, unless otherwise specified. We have additional options available for a small charge, upon request. If you don’t see what you’re looking for, just give us a shout and we’ll do our best to make it happen.
Individually Wrapped
Each cookie is individually sealed in a cellophane bag.
Display Trays
We’ll work to find the right tray for your event.
Celebration Package
Cookies are packed in a box with a display window with a ribbon.
Pricing for Frosted Vanilla Sugar Cookies
Standard
- Minimum 2 Dozen
- 1 Flavor, 2 Designs
- 2-3 Colors, 1-2 Layers
- Typically 3-4 inch cookies
Complex
- Minimum 2 Dozen
- 1 Flavor, 2-3 Designs
- 4+ Colors, 3+ Layers
- Typically 3-4 inch cookies
GET IN TOUCH
Start your cookie order
🎓 Congrats Class of 2025 🧡 Your hard work has paid off! We hope you get to celebrate in style like this grad!
.
.
.
.
.
#classof2025 #classof25 #graduated #graduation #graduation2025 #2025grad #graduationcookies #graduationparty #gradparty #gradphotos #gradnight #2025vibes #seattle #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #seattlecookies #seattlefood #seattledesserts #seattlefoodie #seattlefoodscene #cookie #cookies #cookiegram #cookiesofig #sugarcookies #sugarcookie #frostedsugarcookies #cookieset #cookiedecorating #cookiedecorator
1 week ago
🎓 Congrats Class of 2025 💚 This is an amazing milestone and you should celebrate this sweet success!
.
.
.
.
.
#classof2025 #classof25 #graduated #graduation #graduation2025 #2025grad #graduationcookies #graduationparty #gradparty #gradphotos #gradnight #2025vibes #seattle #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #seattlecookies #seattlefood #seattledesserts #seattlefoodie #seattlefoodscene #cookie #cookies #cookiegram #cookiesofig #sugarcookies #sugarcookie #frostedsugarcookies #cookieset #cookiedecorating #cookiedecorator
1 week ago
🎓 Congrats Class of 2025 ♥️ Your friends and family are so proud of you and this amazing accomplishment!
.
.
.
.
.
#classof2025 #classof25 #graduated #graduation #graduation2025 #2025grad #graduationcookies #graduationparty #gradparty #gradphotos #gradnight #2025vibes #seattle #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #seattlecookies #seattlefood #seattledesserts #seattlefoodie #seattlefoodscene #cookie #cookies #cookiegram #cookiesofig #sugarcookies #sugarcookie #frostedsugarcookies #cookieset #cookiedecorating #cookiedecorator
2 weeks ago
🍅 It’s finally farmers market season! 🥦
While these cookies were actually for a baby shower, we absolutely love the farmers market theme! From broccoli florets to ripe tomatoes, each cookie has its own personality.
.
.
.
.
.
#farmersmarket #farmersmarkettheme #cookieset #farmersmarketcookies #cookiedesign #cookie #cookies #sugarcookie #sugarcookiesofinstagram #sugarcookies #sugarcookiedecorator #sugarcookiedecorating #ballardfarmersmarket #fremontfarmersmarket #edmondsfarmersmarket #seattlefarmersmarket #universitydistrictfarmersmarket #shorelinefarmersmarket #lakecityfarmersmarket #bellevuefarmersmarket #capitolhillfarmersmarket #westseattlefarmersmarket #seattle #seattlebakery #seattledesserts #seattlefood #seattlesmallbusiness #seattlecookies #cookiegram #cookieart
4 weeks ago
♠️ The house (with cookies) always wins ♥️
We made these cookies for a recent @zillow event and we were so happy to add something special to their conversation!
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
#pokercookies #cardcookies♠️♥️♦️♣️ #cardcookies #playingcardcookies #pokertheme #♠️ #♥️ #♣️ #♦️ #sugarcookie #sugarcookiesofinstagram #sugarcookiedecorator #sugarcookiedecorating #cookie #cookies #cookiedecorating #cookiegram #cookieset #eventplanners #eventtheme #corporateevents #corporateevent #frostedsugarcookies #sugarcookiesseattle #seattlecookies #seattlecookieartist #seattlecookieshop #seattle #seattledesserts #seattlebakery
1 month ago
🌞 A delicious Earth Day celebration 🍃 These delightful suns, fresh leaves, and bite-sized Earths recently helped Amazon celebrate Earth Day. And as a bonus, these are also a perfect representation of the wonderful spring we’ve been having in Seattle. Happy Earth Day and Happy Spring!
.
.
.
.
.
.
#seattle #seattlesun #pnw #pnwlife #pnwweather #spring #springtime #earthday #earthday2025 #happyearthday #suncookies #leafcookies #globecookies #earthcookies #mapcookies #seattlebakery #seattlebaker #seattlecookies #pnwcookies #sugarcookies #cookie #cookies #frostedsugarcookies #springcookies #springcookieset #cookieset #corporateevents #corporategifts #corporategifting #cookiegram
1 month ago
🏕️ Camp Maddie celebrated in style last weekend 🔥 Looking to celebrate a special occasion with custom treats? Visit our website to get started!
.
.
.
.
.
#bachelorette #bachelorettecookies #bacheloretteparty #bacheloretteweekend #seattlebachelorette #seattleparty #seattlepartyplanner #seattlepartyplanning #seattlebakery #seattlebaker #seattlecookies #seattlebacheloretteparty #seattledesserts #cookies #cookie #cookiegram #cookiesofig #cookiesofinsta #cookiesofinstagram #sugarcookie #sugarcookieart #sugarcookiesdecorating #sugarcookiedecorator #sugarcookieart #frostedsugarcookies #sugarcookies #cookiedecorating #cookieparty #bachelorettetrip #bachelorettepartyideas #campcookies
2 months ago
🫛 Congrats to the Greene fam on your twins 👯 Celebrate your uniqueness with custom sugar cookies! Whether you’re celebrating a new baby, birthday, wedding, or another big life event, we’re here to make your event as special as the people you’re celebrating.
.
.
.
.
.
#twinbaby #twinbabyshower #twinbabyshowercookies #babyshower #babyshowercookies #babycookies #peasinapod #twopeasinapod #twins #twincookies #cutecookies #adorablecookies #cookieideas #seattle #seattlewa #seattledessert #seattlebakery #seattlebaker #seattlefood #seattlefoodscene #cookie #cookies #cookiedecorating #cookieart #cookiegram #cookiesofig #cookiesofinsta #sugarcookie #sugarcookiesofinstagram #sugarcookiesdecorating
2 months ago
👟 Celebrating big steps over here 🏃♂️ These custom Hyperion Elite @brooksrunning cookies were so fun to make, and the Brooks team loved them just as much as us!
.
.
.
.
#brooks #brooksrunning #hyperionelite4 #brooksshoes #brooksseattle #seattlerunning #runningshoes #cookie #cookies #shoecookies #customcookies #customsugarcookies #uniquecookies #cookiegifts #giftcookies #cookiedecorating #cookiegram #cookieart #seattle #seattlebaker #seattlebakery #seattlefood #seattlefoodie #seattledessert #frostedsugarcookies #sugarcookie #sugarcookiesofinstagram #sugarcookiedecorating #customgifts #seattlefoodscene
3 months ago
Let’s work together on your
next corporate gift project!
Looking for a special gift that will leave your clients wanting more?